Image for Listen: Did One Direction Rip Off The Clash?

Listen: Did One Direction Rip Off The Clash?

Written by Mike Hohnen on September 24, 2012

Here’s a bit of a mellon scratcher to wrap up your Monday arvo. Following the recent unveiling of their latest video effort, One Direction have received backlash after fans began commenting on the resemblance Live While We’re Young has to The Clash’s 1981 masterpiece Should I Stay Or Should I Go.

Now, the first question that might pop into your head is ‘why would musicians as talented and virtuous as One Direction feel the need to copy another band’s work?’ Well, people all over the world have been thinking the same, heading to YouTube in droves to compare the two. Music Feeds did the hard work for you (and Ninemsn did the hard work for us) and you can examine both tracks below.

The issue lies in the guitar chords, the strumming pattern and the almost exact usage of palm muting. You don’t even need to hear The Clash hit to remember how that one goes. This begs another question…surely someone, somewhere along the line of command that falls between One Direction and their actual music would have heard the tune and thought ‘…wait a minute’. Just saying.

So check it out below; what do you guys think?

Join Music Feeds on Facebook

More On Music Feeds


Watch Five Finger Death Punch’s Ivan Moody Go On Weird Rant Against Kanye West & Social Media

Ivan Moody (real name Ivan Greening) of Las Vegas nu metal outfit Five Finger Death Punch has had a go at rapper Kanye West and anyone who speaks negatively about him on social media in a brief but pretty Kanye-esque rant at a recent show.

Music Videos

The Drones – ‘Taman Shud’

Perth legends The Drones have made their triumphant return with the snarling new single Taman Shud, complete with a brilliantly whacky music video.


Collective Shout Accuses Tyler, The Creator Of Having “A Tantrum” On New Song ‘Fuck It’

Since calling out Australia’s visa laws on his new song Fuck It, rapper Tyler, The Creator has been accused of having “a tantrum to music” by Collective Shout, the activist group which successfully campaigned to have the rapper banned from touring Australia for “misogynistic hate speech against women, as well as homophobia”.


Roland Tings Leads Latest The Island LIVE Lineup

Now that Sydney Harbour’s The Island has officially launched The Island LIVE for spring and summer, the event is returning this November with the likes of Melbourne dance producer Roland Tings, house DJ and radio announcer CC:Disco, Wordlife member Kato and a special guest whose identity is yet to be announced.


Sticky Fingers Take Aim At Lockout Laws With Cover Of The Specials’ ‘Ghost Town’

Sydney’s Sticky Fingers have addressed their city’s controversial lockout laws by sharing a brand-new single, which is actually a cover of English ska band The Specials‘ classic track Ghost Town.


Bluesfest 2016 Sideshows: Sturgill Simpson, Steve Earle & The Dukes, The Selecter & More

The first lot of Bluesfest sideshows are here, with a few of the acts planning a string of headline shows on top of their appearance at the Byron Bay Festival.

Around the web

This May Also Interest You