The band has been on ice since 2013, when Lambesis was first arrested on suspicion of hiring a hitman to kill his wife. The next year, the metalcore frontman was sentenced to six years hard time for the thwarted murder plot, before being paroled at the end of 2016 after serving less than half of that sentence.
Fast-forward to this week, and rumours began circulating that Lambesis had reformed with his old bandmates in AILD, after the group purged their social media pages of all past content and posted a new video teaser, obscuring the identity of all members.
But there was also doubt cast upon the makeup of the band’s revived lineup, in the wake of guitarist Nick Hipa categorically denouncing his disgraced frontman as a “sociopathic narcissist in definite need of rehabilitation” in a damning post back in 2014.
But it seems like that’s all water under the bridge now, because AILD have just revealed their entire classic lineup — Hipa and Lambesis included — are back together.
And the gaping divide between fans’ reactions has so far been nothing short of incredible:
As I Lay Dying is back!!!! I’m so happy right now!!!
— abbie (@AwPuddinCmon) June 8, 2018
I am seriously like a kid on Christmas excited that As I Lay Dying are back.
— Jeff (@doctormagikk) June 8, 2018
As I Lay Dying kinda got me into heavy bands but I'm not supporting a new incarnation of that band with that piece of human garbage Tim Lambesis involved. I mean, I wouldn't really care about it anyway, but fuck that (attempted) wife murdering scumbag.
— Intoxicated By Malice (@Averylikespizza) June 8, 2018
Fark. As I Lay Dying has a new song out… but I can’t happily jam out to it knowing that homeboy tried to have someone murder his wife. People are insane.
— momo yuuka (@yxngnica) June 8, 2018
— farter juan twisty (@Toeknee666) June 8, 2018
To anyone that says Tim Lambesis has done his time and should be forgiven: You're wrong.
Dude tried hiring a hitman to kill his wife. That's some coldblooded shit, man.
— Allan Foster (@TotesAllan) June 8, 2018
With lyrics like “I know I lost my way” and “Buried alive inside my own grave / there’s no one else to blame… Finally forced to face what I’ve become”, it’s clear that Lambesis’ lyrics could be pretty autobiographical on this one.
And plenty of the conflict inside fans’ hearts also seems to come from the fact that the song, to put it honestly, doesn’t suck.
Ugggg… I feel so weird about new As I Lay Dying. It'd be so much easier if the song sucked. But it rips so hard.
— Ancient Colossal Bassist Ian (@redberen) June 8, 2018
Just heard the new As I Lay Dying again. I don’t give a flying fuck, that song rips
— Big Dog (@JoetheBigDog) June 8, 2018
If you feel up to it, you can check out the song for yourself below and let us know how you feel about As I Lay Dying’s comeback with Tim Lambesis in the comments.